Are There Contradictions and Ambiguities in Chapter 1 of Capital?
ثبت نشده
چکیده
Geert suggested in his Omaha paper that, in Chapter 1 of Volume 1 of Capital, there is a “shift” in Marx’s logic from Sections 1 and 2 to Section 3, and that this shift may not get the attention of the reader if Section 3 is read “with the labor-embodied spectacles” of Sections 1 and 2 (pp. 1112). Geert does not specify the precise nature of this “shift”, but the suggestion seems to be that there is a fundamental shift in the type of logical method employed and in the basic theory of value, from a labor theory of value to a value-form theory of value. Elsewhere, Geert has argued that there are “two streams” in Marx’s texts – a labor-embodied stream and a value-form stream.
منابع مشابه
The Iinterpretative Analysis of Verse 213 of Chapter Bagherah in Fariqain (Sunni and Shia) Interpretations
The issue of the unity and difference of humans is rooted in the history of man’s social life, and this is the basis for the emergence of divine prophets and the revelation of the heavenly books. With a brief overview of this issue, Verse 213 of chapter Bagherah explains the evolution of human thought in different stages. There are many ambiguities about the nature of the basis of unity, the ca...
متن کاملCritical Analysis of Opinions of Scholiasts on Uncertainties of 16th Ayah (verse) of Al-Isra Surah (chapter) - A Survey of Ayah’s Purpose
During analysis, sometimes the details of Ayahs (verses) cause ambiguities or uncertainties in the mind. To merely focus on resolving ambiguities with no attention to the main idea of the verse, can make difficulties in answering such uncertainties and a reduction in understandings as well; the matter is explicitly observable in the pertinent Ayah (16 / Al-Isra). The present research, bes...
متن کاملمقایسه کارایی سرمایهگذاری در بخشهای خصوصی و دولتی در ایران رویکردی برای خصوصیسازی
Developed and Developing countries have remarkably pursued privatization policies during recent decades. The successes followed by performing this policy in developing countries, the collapse of totally concentrated and governmental economic systems and the polices of international economic agential program of economic structure reforms. Although the results of performing this policy have been ...
متن کاملThe Latest Lithic Industry of Zagros Pleistocene: Ambiguities and Contradictions in Zarzian Studies
Introduction The final phase of Late Paleolithic of Zagros Mountains has been introduced as the Zarzian of the Epipaleolithic (EP), which was defined based on the assemblage from type site of Zarzi Cave in Iraqi Kurdistan. This techno-complex has been much less investigated and introduced in comparison to the earlier groups of Upper Paleolithic. The Zarzian is a microlithic industry with smal...
متن کاملبررسی ماهیت هیأت داوری موضوع ماده ۳۰ قانون اجرای سیاستهای کلی اصل ۴۴ با نگاهی به رویه قضایی
Under the third chapter of Iran's Third Five-year Development Plan, titled as "Ceding the Shares and Management of Governmental Companies", an arbitration panel is established for settling the disputes arising out of ceding processes. This panel was further validated in the article 30 of the Law on Implementation of General Policies of Principle 44. However, a question might arise that whether...
متن کامل